Succession Valuations for Wollongong and Illawarra Family Businesses

Passing a business to a daughter, son or long-serving relative has to pay for the founder's retirement, leave the successor something that can carry its price, look even-handed to the children who stay out of it and satisfy both the ATO and Revenue NSW. All four checks start with what the business is worth.

Indicative valuations from A$799. Certified Summary and Detailed reports from seven business days.

A succession valuation puts a market value on a Wollongong family business, or on the shares or units changing hands, at the date control passes to the next generation. The ATO uses market value for dealings between relatives whatever price is paid, so this single number shapes sibling equalisation, what the successor can fund and any Division 152 relief.

Four people rely on the same number

Family-owned firms are common across the Illawarra, and many of their founders are now closer to retirement than to starting out: fabrication and engineering workshops around Port Kembla and Unanderra, builders and trades businesses serving new housing at Dapto and Albion Park Rail, cafe and accommodation owners in Kiama and Shellharbour, and professional practices along Crown Street and in North Wollongong. Plenty would rather hand over to a daughter, son or trusted relative than sell to a stranger. It is also the exit that gets the least scrutiny, because no outside buyer tests the price and often no price is ever fixed.

The number matters because several people lean on it. The founder has to know whether the business can fund retirement. The successor needs something that can service the price. The children outside the business need to see they were treated evenly. And for tax, the ATO treats a dealing between relatives as made at market value, whatever actually passed across.

With no agreed figure, a family negotiates by instinct. With one, the questions turn practical: how much, paid how, over what period, and what everyone else receives in return. Sibling disputes over a family business are among the most bitter we are asked to help with, and most trace back to a value that was assumed instead of established. They can resurface years later as a family provision claim under the Succession Act 2006 (NSW), which in some circumstances lets the Court treat property transferred before death as notional estate.

We value businesses, shareholdings and unit holdings for families across Wollongong, Shellharbour, Kiama and the wider Illawarra, from a Unanderra engineering workshop to a Fairy Meadow professional practice. The valuer sets the market value and explains it to everyone at the table; your accountant and lawyer then build the transfer around it.

Book a Free Consultation

A certified valuer will listen to your situation and answer any questions you may have, at no cost.

Andrew Mackson
Andrew Mackson, CFA, ABV, CBV
Managing Partner · 15+ years
Book a Free Consultation →

Why a family handover is tested at market value

A handover can feel like a gift and still be a transaction for tax, for duty and for anyone who contests it later. Your tax adviser applies each rule below; the valuer supplies the market value they are measured against.

Division 152 and the 15-year exemption

The 15-year exemption fits succession well. Where an owner aged 55 or over has held the asset for at least 15 years and disposes of it in connection with retirement, the whole capital gain can be disregarded. Eligibility depends on the $2 million aggregated turnover test or the $6 million net asset test applied just before the transfer, and the net asset test is itself a valuation covering the owner, connected entities and affiliates.

Market value overrides the family price

Between relatives, tax law puts aside the price actually paid and uses market value in its place. Shares moved at book value, for a token sum or as a gift still produce a capital gain measured on what the parcel was really worth, and an understated figure can be reopened years afterwards with shortfall interest and penalties.

Revenue NSW and duty

If the handover includes the business premises, or an interest in a landholding company or trust, duty under the Duties Act 1997 (NSW) may come into question, including its landholder duty provisions, and Revenue NSW can look to the value of the property rather than the family price. Whether duty applies, and how much, is for your lawyer to confirm; our land and business figures give them values to work from.

Division 7A and the family company

Division 7A can treat a shortfall as a deemed dividend when a private company's business, or value from it, moves to a shareholder or associate for less than market consideration. It tends to be set off by accident: a discounted share transfer, an unpaid present entitlement or a family loan nobody put in writing.

Superannuation planning should run alongside these rules. A gain covered by the 15-year or retirement exemption can go into super under the CGT cap, outside the usual contribution caps, but only if the election reaches the fund no later than the contribution. If it does not, the benefit is generally lost, because the missed step cannot be fixed afterwards.

Start two years early

A valuation taken on the day of transfer records the position; one taken well beforehand can still change it. That leaves time to lift value drivers, to restructure so the Division 152 tests are met, to lengthen the handover and to let the family talk without a deadline. The most useful succession valuations are the ones nobody has to commission yet.

How a family business is valued for a handover

The test is market value: what the business, or the parcel being passed on, would fetch between an informed, willing buyer and an informed, willing seller, neither acting under pressure. That is deliberately an outsider's figure. It is not what the successor can afford, what the founder hopes for or what keeps the siblings content, though showing it to everyone usually eases all three discussions.

Where the business is an established trader, the income approach takes the lead. Future maintainable earnings are capitalised at a rate that reflects how likely they are to continue once the founder steps away, which in succession is the central risk. Where customers, supplier terms, licences or technical know-how sit with the founder personally, part of the earnings will not make the journey, so the valuation separates goodwill that stays with the business from goodwill that leaves with the person. A Port Kembla fabrication shop whose key customers deal only with the founder is a different asset from one where the successor has managed those accounts for ten years.

The market approach cross-checks the result against sales of comparable businesses, and shows the family what an outside sale could realistically achieve as the alternative. The asset approach sets the floor, and for any business that owns its premises, such as a Unanderra workshop or a Kiama accommodation property, it is often the figure that matters most, because the land can be worth several times the operating business on it.

What we work through on every family handover

Where handovers priced on a hunch come undone

These patterns turn up when a family handover reaches us after the event, usually because the business is now being sold or a will is being contested in the Supreme Court of New South Wales in Sydney.

Report Types and Pricing: Valuations From A$799

How deep the report goes depends on who will rely on the figure and how closely it may be examined later. A founder still testing whether retirement is affordable is well served by a clear internal view first. Once the value fixes a transfer price, supports a Division 152 claim or settles what each child receives, it should be certified.

Indicative Valuation
From A$799
Choose this if you want to know whether the business can fund your retirement, whether a family handover is realistic, or which value drivers to work on beforehand. Intended for internal decision-making; it is not a certified opinion for lenders, courts or the ATO.
Delivery: from seven business days after receipt of all information
Up to 50 pages
Internal audience
Can be used in litigation
Capital structure: common equity, bank/shareholder loans
Compliant with ATO market value guidance
APES 225 Valuation Engagement
Certified and signed by an experienced practitioner
Completed and reviewed by well trained staff
Considers and applies, when relevant, all 3 valuation approaches (income, market, asset)
Applies multiple cost of capital estimates (limited to 3)
Executive summary
Statement of limiting conditions
Valuation exhibits
Glossary
Table of contents
Company review
Industry review
Economic review
Discussion of valuation approaches and types of discounts
Discussion of the application of valuation approaches and discounts
Conclusion
Email support
Closing Zoom Call
Detailed Valuation
Contact for Pricing
Choose this where the family is divided, where a family provision claim or estate dispute is foreseeable, or where the transfer runs through a group that the ATO, Revenue NSW or the Supreme Court of New South Wales may examine years later. Certified and signed. Applies and reconciles all relevant approaches in full so another expert can follow the reasoning.
Delivery: from seven business days after receipt of all information
150+ pages
Internal and external audience, including for litigation or when likely to be reviewed by others
Can be used in litigation by a broad range of professionals
Capital structure: common equity, bank/shareholder loans
Compliant with ATO market value guidance
APES 225 Valuation Engagement
Certified and signed by an experienced practitioner
Completed and reviewed by well trained staff
Considers and applies, when relevant, all 3 valuation approaches (income, market, asset)
Applies multiple cost of capital estimates (full set of 12)
Executive summary
Statement of limiting conditions
Valuation exhibits
Glossary
Table of contents
Company review (full)
Industry review (full)
Economic review (full)
Discussion of valuation approaches and types of discounts (full)
Discussion of the application of valuation approaches and discounts (full)
Conclusion
Email support
Closing Zoom Call

See the full Services and Pricing page

What the report records and who stands behind it

Each report states the purpose, the standard and premise of value, the valuation date and the information relied on. Each normalisation is set out alongside the reason for it. The report shows how reliance on the founder was assessed and what it did to value, links the capitalisation rate and any multiple to named sources, and reconciles the approaches into a range with the weighting explained plainly. Where control, a minority parcel or a staged tranche changes the answer, each is valued on its own so the family sees the complete picture.

Family transfers are often reopened long afterwards, sometimes a decade on, when the business is sold or a family provision claim comes before the Supreme Court of New South Wales in Sydney, or a related commercial dispute reaches the District Court at Wollongong. An expert's report in those courts must meet the Expert Witness Code of Conduct in the court rules. We write it so a reader who took no part in the family discussions can follow it. A certified valuer signs it, walks your accountant, lawyer and family through it, and defends it if the ATO, Revenue NSW or another expert disputes it.

The test every founder should apply

Suppose one of my children challenged this handover in ten years. Would the report alone show why the figure was right on the day? If the answer depends on anyone's memory, the valuation has not done its job.

What Illawarra families ask before handing on the business

Yes. Giving a business away is still a disposal for tax, and between relatives the law replaces whatever was paid, even nothing, with market value. The capital gain, any Division 152 concession and any Division 7A exposure all depend on a market value that someone has to establish, and a certified valuation at the transfer date is the evidence of it. Without one, the figure is rebuilt years later from patchy records and the children have no common number to agree on.
It can, and it often fits a family handover well. Where the owner has held the asset continuously for at least 15 years, is 55 or over and is disposing of it in connection with retirement, the entire capital gain can be disregarded, once the basic conditions are met: aggregated turnover under $2 million, or net assets of no more than $6 million at market value across the owner, connected entities and affiliates, tested just before the transfer. Your tax adviser decides whether the conditions are met; our valuation supplies the market values behind the net asset test.
Start with knowing what the business is worth, because every option is measured against that figure. With it agreed, the family can choose equal value, equal shares or a deliberately unequal split that is explained, balanced using other assets, life insurance, instalments paid by the successor or an interest the founder retains. Guesswork is what fails. If siblings learn after the founder's death that the business was worth far more than they were told, a family provision claim under the Succession Act 2006 (NSW) is a common result.
Usually to some extent, and a careful valuation shows how much. Relationships, supplier terms, licences and know-how held by the founder do not transfer automatically, and unless a planned transition passes them on, part of the earnings leaves with you. The valuer splits goodwill belonging to the business from goodwill belonging to you personally. That shows the price a successor can carry, whether the handover should run longer and what an outside buyer would pay instead.
That is for the family to decide, but it should be decided on figures. The valuer can value the business when she took over day-to-day running and again now, showing how much of the growth happened on her watch. Her below-market wage is adjusted either way, because maintainable earnings must carry a market cost of management. The family can then decide whether she is buying a business or paying for value she largely built.
It depends on what is being transferred, and it is a question for your lawyer or accountant, not the valuer. Land is usually the focus. Moving the premises to a relative, or moving shares or units in a company or trust that holds land, can bring the Duties Act 1997 (NSW) into play, including its landholder duty provisions, and Revenue NSW may look to value instead of the family price. Whether duty reaches other business assets, and whether any concession is available, needs specific advice. We prepare land and business values so one set of figures can serve both the ATO and Revenue NSW.
The trading business and the land are valued separately and then considered together. The business is valued on its maintainable earnings after a market rent has been charged for the premises, and the land is valued as property, which for an industrial site can be a large part of the total. Keeping the two apart lets the family decide whether the land goes to the successor, stays with the founder or is held for the other children, and gives the lawyer the property figure that any Revenue NSW duty question will need.
Certified reports are delivered from seven business days once the information is in. For a family business that usually means three to five years of financial statements and tax returns, current management accounts, a chart showing which entity owns what, any shareholders' agreement or written partnership agreement (without one, a New South Wales partnership generally falls back on the Partnership Act 1892 (NSW)), and a short outline of how the family expects the transfer to work. Where the family first wants to know whether a handover is affordable at all, an Indicative valuation using the same analysis can answer that; it is intended for internal decision-making only.
Indicative valuations start from A$799 and are intended for internal decision-making, so they suit an owner who wants a well-reasoned range before committing to anything. Summary and Detailed reports are certified and are quoted after a free consultation, because the fee depends on the purpose, the number of entities, the state of the records and whether the opinion must withstand review by a court, the ATO or another expert. The fee is confirmed in the engagement letter before work starts, and every report is delivered from seven business days after we receive the information.

Book a Free Consultation

Talk your situation through with a certified valuer before you commit to anything, at no cost.

Andrew Mackson
Andrew Mackson, CFA, ABV, CBV
Managing Partner · 15+ years
Book a Free Consultation →

Related pages

Certified Valuation Reports From Seven Business Days

Every report is signed by a credentialed certified valuer and built to withstand ATO, ASIC, court and bank scrutiny.

Book a Consultation